The But Is It Open? blog

Notes on openness.

Essays on open source, AI systems, licensing and the many dimensions of openness. Alongside the writing of But Is It Open?.

On licensing

The Clause Holding Up OpenMDW

The Linux Foundation asked the OSI to approve OpenMDW-1.1 on August 13. The usual 60-day decision date has passed with no ruling, and the review keeps returning to one sentence: a termination clause that now covers copyright as well as patents.

Read the essay 5 minute read
On openness

Meta's Big Release, Through the Rubric

Meta released Muse Spark Open, an 816B open-weights model under its own license. Running it through the book's rubric: strong access and deployment, permission with strings, thin transparency, and no reproduction path.

Read the essay 4 minute read
On licensing

Kimi K3.1 Pro and the Arithmetic of Open

Full weights for a 2.8T model, under a license that measures your revenue: a negotiated contract above $20M, attribution above 100M users. How conditions like these are enforced — and what that says about the word "open."

Read the essay 4 minute read